Working Paper No. 12-27:
Bundle-of-Sticks Notions in Legal and Economic Scholarship


Eric Claeys

Date Posted: March 2012

Abstract (below)
Full text (original)   PDF file
Full text (most recent) on SSRN


The phrase “bundle of rights” does not serve as an accurate conceptual definition of property.  Nor has that phrase provided a helpful metaphor as used in Ronald Coase’s article “The Problem of Social Cost” (1960) and subsequent legal and economic scholarship. Coase’s usage portrays property rights as a collection of individualized permissions to use an asset, when in sound conceptual usage “property” signifies a domain of authority to decide how to use the asset.  The “bundle” metaphor may be understood to state that an owner has a right to deploy his property in any specific manner fairly implied by his general rights of ownership.  Although this metaphorical usage is helpful, it remains parasitic on a sound conceptual definition of property.  Property is best conceived of as a right securing a normative interest in determining exclusively the use of an asset external to the person of the owner.